$249 – Montauk Lakeside Fall Escape w/Breakfast & Bubbly

Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina
TOP 20 - Sells out quickly!
Duncan Brown
Deal Expert

Why We Love This Deal

Cancel without Fees

Secure your travel dates now and, if you need to cancel your booking, you can do so 14 days prior to arrival without fees.

The reviews are in, and Travelzoo members love Gurney's Star Island for its top-notch service and beautiful setting. With this fall deal, you can skip the summer crowds — and exorbitant hotel prices — while nabbing a room, plus breakfast and a bottle of bubbly, from $249 per night into November.

"Home away from home with unparalleled service and hospitality" — Travelzoo Member Review

What's Included

  • Stay in a Standard King or Two Double Room, Sundays-Thursdays
    • $249 per night ... Oct. 11 - Nov. 7
    • $299 per night ... now through Oct. 6
  • Travelzoo member perks:
    • Welcome bottle of Prosecco upon arrival ($48 value)
    • Daily breakfast for two (up to $60 value)
  • Note: Due to local guidelines, some amenities and services may be limited or closed during your visit; please contact the hotel for more details.

What You Need to Know

  • Cancellation Policy: Cancellations must be made at least 14 days prior to arrival; cancellations made after this time will forfeit a deposit of the first night's room, tax and resort fee charged at time of booking
  • 2-night minimum stay required Nov. 5-6
  • Price based on up to two guests sharing a room; higher rates apply for additional guests
  • Children 17 and under stay free of charge when using existing hotel bedding
  • No matter where you book, this hotel charges a resort fee of 15% of the total booking; the fee covers Wi-Fi, pool access, shuttle service and more
  • Self-parking is complimentary
  • Pet-friendly; additional fees apply
  • For more details, see "Policies" and "Amenities" sections

Enjoyed This
"The rooms were fantastic! The service was probably the best I’ve had. Shoutout to Emily at front desk ! And the location and weather superb. Loved the pool and the outside bar. Give me another deal ASAP !!!!"
Jun 11, 2021 - Eastchester, NY, USA
See All 91 Member Ratings

Why We Love This Hotel

  • The resort occupies the former Montauk Yacht club, whose membership included the Vanderbilts, Astors and Charles Lindbergh 
  • You can still find old-school features like the Yacht Club's original lighthouse
  • Rooms here come with high-end perks like Nespresso machines, wet bars and private balconies — sunset cocktails anyone?
  • There are three new restaurants on site that are "worth the stay alone" (Conde Nast Traveler)
  • Stay with confidence — read more about the hotel's enhanced safety and cleaning procedures


If you're looking for modern sophistication inside of historic digs, you'll find it at Gurney's Star Island: The former Montauk Yacht Club once played host to business tycoons like the Vanderbilts and the Astors — Charles Lindbergh frequently landed his seaplane at the on-site marina. However, following a multimillion-dollar renovation finished in 2019, the resort now boasts contemporary décor and amenities, like the redesigned indoor and outdoor pools, three brand-new restaurants and a swanky stretch of private beach on Lake Montauk complete with cocktail service.

Guest rooms feel spacious and bright, thanks to their off-white color palette and sliding-glass doors that open up to private balconies — some feature views of the marina. They also come with upscale perks like rainfall showers, Nespresso machines, wet bars, large flat-panel TVs and "exquisitely comfortable mattresses" (Conde Nast Traveler).

The resort's flagship restaurant, Showfish, almost exclusively uses ingredients sourced within a 20-mile radius, and fittingly specializes in fresh-caught seafood. You can also grab light snacks and libations from the Pool Club; however, for lunch (or late-night munchies), we're especially fond of Il Forno market and café, where you'll find home-made pizza prepared in a 360-degree rotating oven.



  • Infant cots / cribs
  • Bar
  • Fitness classes
  • Games room
  • Gym / fitness center
  • Indoor pool
  • Outdoor pool
  • Pool bar
  • Private beach
  • Restaurant
  • Tennis courts
  • Pet-friendly
  • 100% smoke-free
  • Steam Room


  • Concierge service
  • Room service (limited hours)
  • ATM
  • Currency exchange

Room amenities

  • Air-conditioning
  • Central heating
  • Coffee / tea-making facilities
  • Fridge
  • Iron and ironing board
  • Outdoor space for some rooms
  • Safe
  • Flatscreen TV
  • iPod/iPhone docking station


  • Internet access


  • Bathrobes
  • Hair-dryer
  • Slippers
  • Bathtub or shower


  • Complimentary parking


  • Accessible bathroom in some rooms
  • Accessible parking
  • Accessible restaurant
  • ADA compliant rooms
  • Roll-in shower


Check-in: Standard Time is 4pm.
Minimum age required to check in: 21.

Checkout: Standard Time is 11am.

Children and additional guests: Children 17 and under stay free of charge when using existing bedding.
Crib/Pack 'n Play available upon request: free of charge.
Extra beds are not available.
Extra guest charges will apply as follows:
$25 plus tax per night for older children and adults.

Pets: Pets are allowed on request.
Maximum weight: 40 pounds.

Pet fees are based on length of stay: $75.00 USD (subject to tax) per stay for 1 night stays and $150.00 USD (subject to tax) per stay for stays of 2 nights or more. Charges will be added to your bill at the hotel.

Fees: A resort/facility fee of 15% per room per night will be included in the total price messaged on the checkout page.

The resort/ facility fee includes:

  • Access to all facilities
  • Wi-fi
  • Indoor and outdoor pool (seasonal)
  • Kayaks and paddleboards (seasonal)
  • Bikes
  • Shuttle service to town and to Gurney's Montauk
  • Access to facilities at Gurney's Montauk

Additional details: Due to local and state guidelines, some amenities and services may be limited or closed during your visit; please contact the hotel for more details.

Visit for more details.

  • The restaurants offer outdoor and partial indoor seating.
  • Housekeeping service is daily, turndown is upon request.

Save $250 per night

$249 / night


When You Can Go

Now through Nov. 8

Rates may vary by date, are subject to availability and are not guaranteed until your purchase is complete.

Please note: Some amenities and services may not be available in all rooms or may incur an additional charge. All prices stated have been verified at the time of publication and may vary at the discretion of the hotel.

Enjoyed This
(91 Member Ratings)
Ratings & reviews reflect verified member feedback for Gurney's Star Island Resort & Marina over the past 32 months.
4.7 Ambiance
4.7 Location
4.6 Rooms
4.7 Quality of Service
4.3 Value for the Money
Show Reviews
Enjoyed Most
Beautiful resort, rooms, etc. Wasn't thrilled with the location (corner) of our unit as we had little to no view.
Peter Jun 16, 2021 Byram Township, NJ, USA
Enjoyed Most
Was a girls getaway wonderful time
Other Comments
The staff were very professional and accommodating Special thanks to Emily at the reception desk She is an amazing asset to Gurneys .
Patrucua Jun 13, 2021 Point Lookout, NY, USA
Enjoyed Most
I asked for a water view, got a parking lot view. I need handicapped parking, didn’t get it, they were resealing the parking lot. We were supposed to have a bottle of Prosecco in our room when we arrived, not there and never got it after asking at least 3 times. When we checked out and asked for the $48 value of the bottle to be deducted from our bill they would only give us 15% off the hotel usage fee. When we asked for late checkout they said no, 11:30am only. They seemed very disorganized!
Susan Jun 10, 2021 Stony Brook, NY, USA
Enjoyed Most
The renovations were lovely. The staff was friendly. It seemed like the resort was empty.
Other Comments
The temperature control in the room didn’t work, the kids woke up in a sweat. We did not receive the Prosecco upon check in - had to remind them in the evening to bring it. The indoor pool was supposed to open at 9, but by 9:20 there was still no one there when I went to the front office they said it should be open - someone eventually came around 9:30z
MariAngela Jun 12, 2021 Bronx County, NY, USA
Enjoyed Most
The rooms were fantastic! The service was probably the best I’ve had. Shoutout to Emily at front desk ! And the location and weather superb. Loved the pool and the outside bar. Give me another deal ASAP !!!!
Sian Jun 11, 2021 Eastchester, NY, USA
Enjoyed Most
Overall a great experience
Andrew Jun 11, 2021 Inwood, NY, USA
Other Comments
Went to Showfish for dinner and breakfast. Great restaurant.
Scott May 29, 2021 Farmingville, NY, USA
Enjoyed Most
My experience with Gurney's was top notch. I went to the other one first and was afraid I might be disappointed but when I got there I was pleasantly surprised. From Emily at reception, to the staff and food at the restaurant, not to mention the indoor and outdoor pool, I was highly satisfied with my trip.
Onedia May 28, 2021 Brroklyn, NY, USA
Enjoyed Most
The room was nice, but faced the parking lot (not the water).
Other Comments
There were not many food options, and not much around the hotel. Many things were closed. After informing the waiter at the hotel restaurant of my severe food allergy, he told me he couldn’t make any substitutions because “the chef doesn’t like when we make substitutions.” Most of the staff we encountered was rude/ unpleasant. The food was overpriced, small portions, and not very good.
Samantha May 29, 2021 Southington, CT, USA
Enjoyed Most
A woman at reception welcomed us - ask if there was anything we needed to let her know. She was awesome and made our stay there pleasant -
Other Comments
The staff was friendly - The place was super clean and everyone was conscious - staying there distance and wearing mask if necessary
Gladys May 29, 2021 New York, NY, USA

More Deals & Tips

$249 – Montauk Lakeside Fall Escape w/Breakfast & Bubbly

Save $250 per night

$249 / night

Top 20 Deal — Sells Out Quickly