We use cookies to optimise your experience on Travelzoo. By using our website, you are agreeing to allow this. For more information, see our Privacy & Cookie Policy »

  1. Long Island
  2. $39 - Steak & Seafood Dinner for 2 Praised by Zagat, 50% Off
Deal Cart (0)
Updating Deal Cart
Order Total
Proceed to Payment
Your deal cart is empty. When you add a deal, it will appear here. Updating Deal Cart

$39 - Steak & Seafood Dinner for 2 Praised by Zagat, 50% Off

Sold out - This deal was published February 08, 2013 and sold out February 20, 2013.
$39 - Steak & Seafood Dinner for 2 Praised by Zagat, 50% Off
By Travelzoo Staff
Zagat says Mill Creek Tavern "lures you back like a magnet" with its large menu and friendly atmosphere. For $39, regularly $80, two can savor a three-course dinner at this Bayville gem that The New York Times says has all "the earmarks of a popular neighborhood spot."

Why we love it

  • Nestle into the cozy ambiance of Mill Creek Tavern with a 3-course dinner for 2
  • For $39, select an appetizer, 2 entrees and a dessert from anything on the menu
  • Zagat rates the cuisine at this Bayville gem "very good to excellent" (21)
  • Or for $75, make it an evening with friends and get the same deal for a group of 4


Feb. 7, 2013 - June 11, 2013


Mill Creek Tavern
275 Bayville Ave.
Bayville, NY 11709
(See Map)
Tel: 516-628-2000

What's included

  • Try anything from the menu with this deal that includes:
  • Any shared appetizer, like chilled jumbo shrimp cocktail, crispy calamari or baked clams
  • Any two entrees, with choices like pan-seared sea scallops with lobster asparagus risotto, surf and turf or the 16-ounce New York prime rib sirloin
  • Any shared dessert; select from options like a warm apple sundae, root beer float and bananas Foster (excludes the dessert sampler)
  • Or for $75, regularly $160, make it an evening for four with a deal for two appetizers, four entrees and two desserts.

The fine print

Vouchers can be redeemed starting Monday, Feb. 11, through June 11, 2013. Reservations are required and subject to availability. Limit 1 voucher purchase per person; additional vouchers may be purchased as gifts. Limit 1 voucher per table. Not valid on major holidays or holiday weekends. See below for full terms and conditions.

See all terms
$39   $79.80
51% off | 291 bought
Travelzoo deal by
Mill Creek Tavern
91% Enjoyed Mill Creek Tavern
91% (82 ratings)
Sold out at
11:00 p.m. CT on Feb. 20


M – F, 9am – 9pm ET

91% Enjoyed Mill Creek Tavern
(82 ratings)
Quality of Service
Overall Enjoyed Most Other Comments

The service was slow (though friendly when available). The food was very underwhelming, a seafood fra diavalo dish was bland and the mussels were just bad, and calamari was hard and chewy.The surf & turf was a joke, one shrimp (with tail on) was hidden under bland, poorly cooked risotto ($27.95!). Even the filet mignon (the turf), which consisted of 3 medallions was bland. Clearly, the chef was not using any seasoning or tasting anything before it left the kitchen. We also had a seafood pot pie that contained 2 shrimp, 2 sea scallops and that's it (aside from some potato, peas, and carrots). Even with this voucher deal, I left there feeling like I paid way too much. The only bright spot was the dessert, Juniors cheesecake, cooked elsewhere, they couldn't screw that up!

Jun 12, 2013 Dan New York, United States


Jun 09, 2013 Richard New York, United States


May 15, 2013 Rocky New York, United States

Great experience, cozy place and excellent quality of service.


Apr 18, 2013 Nicholas New York, United States

My husband and I were pleasantly surprised as to how nice this whole experience was. The food, service, decor was very impressive. We will be back!

Apr 08, 2013 Theresa New York, United States

Like this deal? Share it with your friends

275 Bayville Ave.
Bayville, NY 11709
Tel: 516-628-2000

We are now transferring you...

We are now directing you to {0} where you can purchase today’s Travelzoo Local Deal directly.

OK | Cancel

This Travelzoo Local Deal at Mill Creek Tavern sold out at 11:00 p.m. CT on Feb. 20 when 291 vouchers were purchased.

Never miss a Long Island Local Deal again! Sign up to receive Local Deal alerts via email.

  • Your Email:
  • Postcode: